A Practical Guide to Auditing Generative AI Systems in the Public Sector

a{text-decoration:none;color:#464feb}

As public sector organizations increasingly adopt generative AI (GenAI) technologies, it is important to revisit auditing methodologies to ensure compliance, security, fairness, and transparency. Whether you're conducting an audit for regulatory alignment or to mitigate organizational risks, a structured approach can help identify vulnerabilities and safeguard public interest.

Establishing an AI Auditing Framework

An effective GenAI audit framework should assess regulatory and compliance risks, data governance, business process implications, and technology infrastructure security. Here are key focus areas:

• Regulatory and Compliance Risk: Ensure alignment with global, national, and sector-specific regulations. Frameworks such as the NIST AI Risk Management Framework emphasize trustworthiness and accountability in AI systems.
• Data Domain Risk: Evaluate risks related to misinformation, intellectual property concerns, and bias amplification. Strong data governance, as emphasized in the Government of Canada's AI strategy, is critical.
• Business Process Risk: Assess overreliance on AI, quality control mechanisms, and supplier accountability.
• Technology Infrastructure Risk: Ensure model robustness, security, and transparency to minimize vulnerabilities and enhance reliability.

AI Auditing Methodology and Approach

A well-defined methodology ensures AI systems are transparent, secure, and compliant. The following components form the foundation of a structured AI audit:

• Governance: Verify that AI governance policies and accountability measures are in place. The Government of the United States' AI Accountability Framework emphasizes governance as a key principle.
• Impact Assessment: Evaluate AI's societal, environmental, and ethical impacts to minimize harm and maximize benefits.
• Data and Model Lifecycle Management: Review data collection, labeling, validation, training, deployment, and monitoring practices.
• Diversity and Inclusiveness: Assess whether AI models fairly represent diverse populations and mitigate bias.
• Continuous Auditing and Monitoring: Establish ongoing oversight mechanisms to detect emerging risks and policy changes.

The AI Auditing Process Workflow

To systematically audit GenAI systems, follow these six key steps:

1. Establish Audit Objectives: Define compliance, ethical, and security goals.
2. Scope and Planning: Identify stakeholders, system components, and third-party dependencies.
3. Conduct Risk Assessments: Evaluate privacy measures, technological capabilities, and documentation compliance.
4. Publish Audit Findings: Provide transparent reports with actionable recommendations.
5. Verify Implementation of Recommendations: Ensure proper integration of control measures.
6. Continuous Improvement: Establish KPIs to track adherence and evolving risks.

Key Considerations for Auditing GenAI Models

When auditing GenAI systems, specific technical and operational factors must be considered:

• Scale: Assess the number of users, AI agents, and applications built on the model.
• Use Restrictions: Ensure high-risk applications comply with usage restrictions.
• Generality and Autonomy: Evaluate the AI's flexibility across different use cases and levels of independence.
• Tool Use and Model Access: Monitor external integrations such as APIs, web browsing, and robotic control.
• Oversight and Moderation: Ensure human oversight mechanisms are in place.
• Threat Modeling and Lifecycle Management: Identify vulnerabilities and evaluate AI safety from development to decommissioning.
• IT and Business Alignment: Ensure AI implementation aligns with strategic and operational needs.

Building a Responsible AI Framework

A responsible AI framework integrates governance, risk management, ethics, and regulatory compliance. Core principles include:

• Data and AI Ethics: Promote fairness, transparency, and accountability.
• Security and Privacy: Ensure AI models comply with data protection laws.
• Bias and Fairness: Identify and mitigate unintended biases.
• Sustainability and Explainability: Enhance environmental responsibility and model interpretability. The European Commission's AI strategy emphasizes the importance of lawful, safe, and trustworthy AI systems.

Guidelines for Effective GenAI Auditing

Public sector organizations should adhere to these best practices:

• Establish Ethical Standards: Develop and enforce AI ethics policies.
• Enhance Data Governance: Implement strict data quality, privacy, and integrity measures.
• Ensure Transparency and Explainability: Make AI decision-making processes understandable.
• Engage Stakeholders: Involve policymakers, citizens, and domain experts in AI governance.
• Monitor and Evaluate Continuously: Regularly audit AI outputs for compliance and impact.
• Promote Risk Management and Governance: Establish oversight committees for ongoing compliance tracking. The Public Service AI Framework from New Zealand provides a structured approach to AI governance.

Final Thoughts

As AI continues to evolve, public sector organizations must take a proactive approach to auditing and governance. By implementing a structured auditing methodology, agencies can foster trust, ensure compliance, and mitigate risks associated with GenAI deployment.

How is your organization approaching AI auditing?