The Problem With “Spray-and-Pray” Acquisition Models

Hello there! 👋 Welcome to the Hyperengage Newsletter where we share insights & trends from industry leaders in B2B SaaS with a special focus on customer journeys.

If you’re new and want to catch up on the SaaS-o-sphere, click the “subscribe” button above.

But anyway let's get started why the “spray-and-pray” approach to customer acquisition is quietly draining growth from so many SaaS teams, and what a smarter, targeted acquisition strategy looks like instead.

In B2B SaaS, your customer acquisition channel isn’t just a marketing choice, it’s a reflection of how well you understand your audience. Many teams still rely on old habits that focus on quantity over quality. The “spray-and-pray” mindset floods inboxes, burns ad budgets, and frustrates both sales teams and buyers. The truth is simple: you can’t win modern customers with outdated methods.

Volume Without Relevance: The Hidden Cost

Spray-and-pray feels productive because it’s easy to scale. You send thousands of messages, see impressions rise, and believe that means progress. But the real cost hides beneath the surface: low engagement, wasted spend, and a damaged brand reputation.

Every untargeted message tells your audience you don’t understand them. The more you send, the less they listen. It’s not about how many people you reach. It’s about how many of the right people you reach with something that truly resonates.

As Viktoria Izdebska, Founder & CEO at Octrace, points out, the ease of mass outreach has become its own downfall:

“Mass emails and have never been distributed in such a pace and speed as now. So basically everybody can do spray-and-pray right now with their target group, which leads to conversion rates basically dropping to zero.” — Viktoria Izdebska

What Spray-and-Pray Actually Looks Like

You’ve seen it before. A generic ad campaign that targets everyone in a broad industry. A cold email that starts with “Hope you’re doing well” and ends with “Book a demo.” A call from a rep who clearly hasn’t read your LinkedIn profile.

These tactics aren’t just inefficient, they’re tone-deaf. They ignore what buyers actually want: relevance. When messages don’t connect to real pain points or goals, even a great product sounds uninteresting. Buyers aren’t rejecting you, they’re rejecting irrelevance.

Why This Approach Refuses to Die

So why do companies keep doing it? Because it’s familiar. It’s fast. And on the surface, it looks measurable. Executives see dashboards full of activity, emails sent, calls made, impressions served, and think the system works.

But activity isn’t the same as progress. The digital landscape has changed. Buyers have more control, more information, and higher expectations. The same tactics that worked a decade ago now erode trust instead of building it.

The Modern Buyer Has Evolved

Today’s buyers are educated long before they speak to sales. They research competitors, read reviews, and talk to peers. They expect outreach to feel personal and informed, not automated and repetitive.

If your first touch feels generic, you’re already behind. Buyers don’t want to be “targeted,” they want to be understood. They want to see that you’ve done your homework, that you recognize their challenges, and that your solution fits into their world.

Targeted Channels Create Meaningful Momentum

Precision beats volume every time. The companies that grow fastest are the ones that invest in targeted customer acquisition channels, approaches that meet buyers where they are with content and timing that match their intent.

Instead of trying to be everywhere, they focus on the few places that matter most. They tailor messaging to specific roles and industries. And they use insights, not instincts, to guide their spend. The result is fewer wasted touches, better conversion, and more meaningful relationships from day one.

Start With Your Ideal Customer Profile

Everything starts with clarity. Your Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) defines who benefits most from your product, and who doesn’t. It includes not just demographics, but behaviors, pains, and motivations.

When your ICP is strong, you know which channels to prioritize and what messaging will land. You stop guessing and start speaking directly to the people most likely to buy. That focus turns marketing from guesswork into strategy.

Design the Journey, Not Just the Message

Customer acquisition isn’t a one-off moment; it’s a sequence of interactions that build trust. Map how your buyers move from problem awareness to decision. Each stage deserves content that meets them where they are.

Instead of flooding inboxes, guide prospects with helpful insights. Teach before you pitch. Share data, success stories, and context that help them make confident decisions. The goal isn’t to push harder, it’s to educate better.

Let Intent and Timing Guide You

Modern tools make it easier than ever to see when a buyer is ready. Website visits, product research, and keyword searches are signals of intent. The most effective teams use this data to reach out at the right time, not all the time.

When you align timing with need, your outreach stops feeling intrusive and starts feeling helpful. You’re not interrupting their day, you’re showing up with value exactly when they need it.

Align Sales and Marketing Around Shared Targets

The disconnect between sales and marketing is often what kills efficiency. Marketing floods the funnel with leads; sales struggles to qualify them. Alignment fixes this.

By adopting Account-Based Marketing (ABM) principles, both teams focus on the same high-value accounts. Every touchpoint, ads, emails, and calls, works together to tell one cohesive story. Buyers notice the difference immediately. The experience feels coordinated, not chaotic.

From Noise to Clarity: The New Path to Growth

The spray-and-pray era is over. In today’s SaaS landscape, relevance is the new reach. The right customer acquisition channel is the one that aligns your message, data, and intent with your buyer’s journey.

Platforms like Hyperengage make this transformation easier. They connect behavioral signals, identify buying intent, and automate personalized engagement, so teams spend less time guessing and more time growing.

If you want sustainable growth, start with focus. Stop trying to reach everyone. Speak directly to the few who matter most. The future of acquisition isn’t about shouting louder, it’s about understanding better.

If you enjoyed reading our newsletter, be sure to leave your thoughts in the comments below and subscribe for insights on what’s going on in the SaaS-o-sphere!