Sprinkle cookies, peanut butter-stuffed cookies, gingerbread and all the spiced goodness — oh my! With so many to choose from, the list is never-ending. Treat yourself to a few bites from these bakers or add them to your holiday cookie lineup for a festive gift exchange.
Big Island Candies
Serving the islands since 1977, Big Island Candies (multiple locations) is a go-to spot for delicious gifts. Its signature shortbread cookies are dipped in a number of chocolates like milk chocolate caramel, dark chocolate, white chocolate and more. Try seasonal flavors like peppermint white-dipped Kona mocha and a cinnamon white-dipped combo box. You’ll save time on wrapping with its beautifully packaged gift boxes as well.
Follow @bigislandcandies on Instagram to see more of its holiday offerings.
Pipeline Bakeshop and Creamery
Pipeline Bakeshop & Creamery (3632 Waialae Ave.) offers numerous homemade cookies. Order one of its large monster cookies like the popular Avery & Molly Monster Cookie that’s named after the bakeshop’s mascots and made from its original cookies and cream dough with brownies, marshmallows and Oreos. For a smaller bite, try one of its cornflake or gingerbread crisps that are sold in bags of 12. This bakeshop also offers nationwide shipping, making it perfect to send to your friends and family abroad.
Visit pipelinebakeshop.com for more information.
Seven4Two Bakery
Specializing in croissants and sourdough, Seven4Two Bakery (various pop-up locations) may not have a physical storefront, but it does offer weekly pickups. Its sourdough cookie flavors include dark chocolate chunk and mac nut chocolate chunk. Both are made from a sourdough starter, then mixed with brown butter, chocolate chunks and macadamia nuts (for the Mac Nut Chocolate Chunk flavor). Don’t miss out on its four pack of cinnamon rolls that go perfectly with its cookies.
Orders open every Sunday. Follow @seven4twobakery on Instagram for order and pickup details.
You Made This For Me
You Made This For Me (various pop-up locations) makes custom cookies from scratch that fit any theme. From holidays to favorite movies and everything local, this bakery makes the perfect iced cookie for any occasion. Popping up at public events — like Honolulu Makers Market at Ala Moana Shopping Center — the business makes standard-sized cookies (3 1/2-4 inches) and mini cookies (2-2 1/2 inches). The business was started in 2019 with the mission of sweetening people’s days without emptying their wallets.
Follow @youmadethisforme on Instagram to see You Made This For Me’s adorable Christmas cookies and more.
Auntie Lolo’s Cookies
Laurie Caty, affectionately known as Auntie Lolo, is the baker behind the North Shore micro-bakery Auntie Lolo’s Cookies (various pop-up locations). Staying connected to the community through donations and participating in local events is what inspires Caty. Cookie flavors include oatmeal chocolate peanut butter, Cookie Monster, cookies ’n’ cream, Gimme S’mores, Ruby Red Velvet and more. You’ll also find little surprises mixed in the dough like Oreo bits, marshmallows and chocolate chips.
For these aloha filled cookies and pop-up schedule, visit @auntieloloscookies on Instagram.
Diamond Bakery Hawaii
Diamond Bakery Hawaii (756 Moowaa St.) recently celebrated its 104th birthday and remains a staple for life’s special moments. At its factory, customers can shop for butter pecan cookies, kakimochi cookies, lychee macadamia shortbread cookies and ube Hawaiian shortbread cookies. For the holidays, the candy cane cookies are a must. The biz also offers fundraising packages to help raise money for your child’s next sports trip or school event.
Visit diamondbakery.com to see more of its fundraising and holiday offerings.
Cookie Corner Hawaii
For a soft and chewy cookie, Cookie Corner Hawaii (multiple locations) is the place to go. With a number of freshly baked cookies to choose from daily, it’s the perfect after-work snack or dessert for home. You can order the original size cookies individually, or in a small box (8-9 cookies), medium tin (11-12 cookies); or large box (17-18 cookies). For a baked gift, go for one of the traditional bite-size or island-style bite-size cookies that are packaged in the iconic red and white Cookie Corner colors.
To see its full cookie menu, visit cookiecorner.com.